CFOs at publicly traded companies typically have good reasons to avoid raising equity capital if they can help it. Investors tend to interpret seasoned equity sales as a sign of poor financial health or that a stock is overpriced. That translates into an almost automatic 3% drop in share price when the offering is announced. For most CFOs, that’s a big pill to swallow.
But equity is making a comeback. Secondary offerings hit $60 billion last May, up from $19 billion in April and just $10 billion in the entire first quarter, according to the Securities Industry and Financial Markets Association.
Why the resurgence? One reason is that companies need to reduce leverage to a manageable level. Paying down debt with equity can take “the going-concern risk associated with high leverage out of play,” says William Welnhofer, a managing director at Robert W. Baird & Co. Thus, investors are more tolerant these days of issuers raising equity to pay down debt, notes David Gruber, head of equity at KeyBanc Capital Markets.
Raising capital is also becoming less expensive, on a relative basis. “The cost of debt has risen and equity has come down slightly, so the gap between the aftertax effective cost of debt and the cost to issue equity has closed,” says Joe Gentile, chief administrative officer at health-care investment bank Leerink Swann.
Finally, issuers are finding eager buyers for their shares. “Assets are flowing into mutual funds, so portfolio managers have the dry powder to buy shares,” says Gruber. In the second quarter, net inflows into equity mutual funds totaled $39 billion, compared with a net outflow in the first quarter, according to AMG Data Services.
But that doesn’t mean raising equity capital is a cakewalk. CFOs have to plan ahead to avoid the effects of dilution and squelch concerns that the stock is trading too high. “Investors have to be able to tell themselves another story about what the company is doing,” notes Charles Cuny, a finance professor at Washington University in St. Louis. “When a company is very clearly taking on new investment and equity is tied to real expansion, the negative impact on the stock price is smaller.”
Short marketing and transaction times, which enable issuers to minimize the effect of market volatility on the share price, are essential. “The longer you are out in the market — with the way the market is moving around — the greater chance you’ll be caught with your pants down,” says Christopher Malik, a senior associate at KeyBanc Capital Markets. In a so-called accelerated book build, a company can sell equity at a discount in one day, filing a press release after the market closes and pricing the transaction the next morning before the market reopens.
A PIPE with a Twist
Many companies are eschewing marketed secondary offerings and turning to private investment in public equity (PIPE). One variety, known as a registered direct deal, is gaining popularity. Of 391 PIPE deals in the first half of 2009, 19% were registered direct, up from 8% last year, according to Sagient Research. In a registered direct deal, the shares are registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission, then marketed to a small group of handpicked investors, who must sign confidentiality agreements and temporarily refrain from trading in the stock.