• Strategy
  • CFO Magazine

Building Better Budgets

New Web-based applications bring budgeting and planning closer to reality.

From VisiCalc to Lotus 1-2-3 to Microsoft Excel, the electronic spreadsheet has earned a special place in the hearts of finance folk. But when budget time rolls around, that affection can be strained — especially at larger companies, where spreadsheets from many users must be combined. “Spreadsheets weren’t designed as a collaborative tool,” says Henry Morris, an analyst at technology research firm IDC, in Framingham, Massachusetts. “Just passing a spreadsheet around gives you no control.” The result is usually a massive key-punching and quality-control exercise at the corporate level, as spreadsheet data from various departments is painstakingly rolled up into one budget. And the pain isn’t limited to finance: fixing broken links has made “the Excel spreadsheet the bane of IT,” says Morris.

Spreadsheet fans have little to fear: Excel is by far the most widely used budgeting and planning (B&P) tool, and it is still a viable solution for many companies. But to reduce the time and effort spent on budgeting, and to marry planning with reality, many companies are turning to B&P software packages. “Usually around January, when the budget cycle ends, we get a huge number of calls from people saying, ‘I have to get a [budgeting] application, because I’m not going through that spreadsheet hell again,’” says Dan Sholler, senior program director at IT consultancy Meta Group, in Stamford, Connecticut.

“The whole budgeting process was taking too much time and precluded us from getting into true financial analysis and strategic planning,” testifies Gordon Khan, CFO of Hunter Douglas Inc., the North American division of Hunter Douglas N.V., a $1.4 billion provider of blinds, shades, and drapes. In addition to its headquarters in Upper Saddle River, New Jersey, Hunter Douglas has 28 operating units, each with its own general manager and controller. “Each division had its own spreadsheets — they weren’t standard,” says Khan. “They would send them by E-mail or diskette, and corporate would have to rekey or upload them into corporate Excel spreadsheets to come up with consolidated financial reporting schedules.” Not counting preparation time, the process of submitting the information and making changes took a month and a half.

“Every time you made a change, it could take a week to get the change through,” recalls Khan. What’s more, the small army of consultants maintaining the company’s spreadsheets cost the company $100,000 a year.

At the end of the first quarter of 1999, Hunter Douglas rolled out Cognos Finance, a B&P tool that was known as Lex 2000 until Cognos Inc. acquired it in March 1999. “Now, when the numbers are entered by the divisions, the consolidation is done,” says Khan. “If they want to change something, they hit a button and the consolidation is changed.” And as soon as consolidation is complete, Cognos automatically produces 20 business review schedules created by Hunter Douglas executives. The system is distributed; budgeting and business review templates are installed at each unit. Khan is concentrating on extending the system down to the departmental level, where spreadsheets are still the norm.


Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *