• Technology
  • CFO Asia

Vive le ROI

The quest to pin down ROI on technology is turning into an industry in itself -- and sending CFOs back to basics.

Sometimes a finance chief has to cut his losses. Just ask Ross Hughes, CFO of Australia-based BankWest. In the early 1990s, executives at the bank, which has assets of more than US$12 billion, went shopping for a core banking system. When they couldn’t find an off-the-shelf package that met their requirements, they built their own. By the end of the decade, BankWest had developed a system it felt other banks might buy. Early signs were good: UK-based Halifax Bank of Scotland, which owns 56 percent of BankWest, snapped it up after a rigorous global tender process. Computing heavyweight IBM thought the system had prospects, too, and came on board in a joint venture to market the system in Asia. Hughes recalls: “We felt we’d created something exceptional.”

But the banks in Asia didn’t bite. So, earlier this year Hughes and his colleagues pulled the plug on plans for export success. The move also had implications for the company’s IT activity at home. In June, BankWest announced it would merge its in-house IT division with CBSIS, the subsidiary that drove development of the core banking system. The creation of a single IT unit would save the company “a few million dollars” by cutting head count and duplication of effort. But more importantly, Hughes says, it would focus IT resources on work that supported the bank’s own strategic agenda.

A retreat, certainly, but BankWest deserves kudos for attempting to transform IT from a cost center to a revenue generator. Besides, a data services and disaster recovery joint venture with the local subsidiary of U.S.-based Unisys is thriving, boasting clients from the government and mining sectors. But even if commercialization of their IT department is the last thing on most companies’ minds, BankWest’s soul-searching is not unique. The economic downturn, coupled with the dot-com burst, has prompted a backlash against IT, and turned the quest to pin down ROI into an industry in itself. Wherever they look for answers amid vendor talk of ROI calculators and consultants debate over the best measurement methodologies, companies want an answer to a universal question. As Hughes observes: “How do I know whether IT adds value to my organization?”

Prima Donna

The relationship between IT and the rest of the business has always been tetchy. Even technology vendors admit that something was amiss. “Before the dot-com bust, technology was pretty much a prima donna,” observes Kuala Lumpur-based Rahul Patwardhan, president of the Asia Pacific and Europe operations of NIIT, the Indian outsourcing giant. “On one hand, this wasn’t good. But if one does not invest in innovation, then someone else will,” he says.

Sam Lo, group financial controller at Singapore-based ECnet, knows all about it. ECnet sells supply-chain solutions, an area full of promise — reflected in a client list that includes Matsushita, Philips, and Toshiba — but relegated to the back burner at many companies. As a result, Lo must rein in costs while ensuring the company doesn’t impair its ability to react when market conditions improve. As a technology purveyor, continued investment in a cutting-edge platform is key, while building internal operational efficiencies.

Discuss

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *